Heathers Off-Broadway Cast: Original Cast Members of Heathers
With the news of Heathers the Musical returning to New York, it’s a great time to look back at the original Heathers Off-Broadway Cast who first brought this darkly funny high school story to the stage.
The off-Broadway production of Heathers the Musical premiered in 2014 at New World Stages, turning the cult classic 1988 film into a live show full of catchy songs and sharp humour.
Let’s take a look at the actors and actresses from the original Heathers Off-Broadway Cast who made this production so memorable.
Key Takeaways
- Heathers Off-Broadway Cast: Discover the original cast members of Heathers the Musical, including Barrett Wilbert Weed as Veronica Sawyer and Ryan McCartan as JD Dean.
- Memorable Performances: Learn about standout performances from the original cast, such as Jessica Keenan Wynn as Heather Chandler and Elle McLemore as Heather McNamara.
- Impact on Musical Theatre: Understand how the original Off-Broadway production set the stage for Heathers the Musical’s success, blending dark humour and catchy songs.
Barrett Wilbert Weed as Veronica Sawyer
Barrett Wilbert Weed played Veronica Sawyer, the smart but conflicted teen who gets mixed up with the Heathers, the most popular (and meanest) girls at Westerberg High.
Weed’s take on Veronica was both sharp and relatable, capturing her struggle to fit in while still trying to do the right thing. Her powerful voice shone in songs like “Dead Girl Walking,” showing off Veronica’s bold side as she navigates the ups and downs of high school drama.
Ryan McCartan as Jason “J.D.” Dean
Ryan McCartan took on the role of Jason “J.D.” Dean, the new kid with a charming but dangerous side. JD quickly becomes close with Veronica, but his dark outlook leads them both down a risky path. McCartan’s performance nailed JD’s mix of charisma and menace, especially in songs like “Freeze Your Brain” and “Meant to Be Yours.” He brought JD’s troubled character to life, making him both intriguing and unsettling to watch.
Jessica Keenan Wynn as Heather Chandler
Jessica Keenan Wynn was Heather Chandler, the confident and ruthless leader of the Heathers. She’s the ultimate high school queen bee who controls everything at Westerberg High. Wynn’s performance as Heather Chandler was spot-on, full of attitude and style, especially in numbers like “Candy Store.” She made Heather Chandler’s presence felt every time she was on stage, perfectly embodying the role of the school’s top girl.
Elle McLemore as Heather McNamara
Elle McLemore played Heather McNamara, the more sensitive member of the Heathers who often feels stuck between her friends’ harsh ways and her own insecurities. McLemore brought a softer touch to the role, making Heather McNamara relatable and sympathetic. Her solo “Lifeboat” gave the audience a glimpse into her character’s struggles, showing that even the popular kids have their own battles.
Alice Lee as Heather Duke
Alice Lee was cast as Heather Duke, who starts off as the quieter Heather but eventually steps up when the opportunity arises. Lee did a great job showing Heather Duke’s transformation from a follower into someone who wants to take charge. Her performance was dynamic, and she added a fresh spin to the character as Heather Duke became bolder and more confident.
Katie Ladner as Martha Dunnstock
Katie Ladner played Martha Dunnstock, Veronica’s sweet but often picked-on friend who becomes a target for the Heathers’ cruel jokes. Ladner’s portrayal of Martha was heartfelt and genuine, especially in “Kindergarten Boyfriend,” where she shares her hopes and memories of a simpler time. Ladner brought a lot of warmth to the role, making Martha one of the most lovable characters in the show.
Evan Todd as Kurt Kelly
Evan Todd took on the role of Kurt Kelly, one of the jocks at Westerberg High who, along with Ram, enjoys bullying the less popular kids. Todd brought plenty of energy to the role, making Kurt Kelly’s over-the-top antics entertaining to watch. He added a comedic layer to the show, balancing out some of the darker moments with his character’s goofy bravado.
Jon Eidson as Ram Sweeney
Jon Eidson played Ram Sweeney, Kurt’s loud and rowdy best friend. Ram, much like Kurt, is part of the popular jock crowd and often joins in on the bullying. Eidson’s performance made Ram a standout in the ensemble, bringing humour and a lot of enthusiasm to the character’s scenes, which added to the chaotic high school atmosphere.
Charissa Hogeland as New Wave Party Girl
Charissa Hogeland appeared as the New Wave Party Girl, a supporting role that added extra flair to the high school setting. Her presence in the ensemble helped build the vibrant and quirky world of Heathers the Musical Off-Broadway, contributing to the lively scenes at Westerberg High.
Cait Fairbanks as Young Republicanette
Cait Fairbanks played the Young Republicanette, another ensemble character who added to the colourful mix of students at Westerberg High. Fairbanks’ performance as part of the ensemble brought an extra layer of fun and satire to the show, rounding out the cast of quirky high schoolers.
Overall
The Heathers Off-Broadway Cast did an incredible job of bringing these iconic characters to life. Barrett Wilbert Weed’s strong portrayal of Veronica and Ryan McCartan’s intense take on JD led the charge, with each of the Heathers adding their own unique spin to the story.
This original off-Broadway production set the tone for what would become a beloved stage adaptation, filled with energy, dark humour, and a little bit of teenage angst that keeps audiences hooked.
FAQs
What is Heathers the Musical Off-Broadway about?
Heathers the Musical Off-Broadway is a dark comedy based on the 1988 cult film “Heathers.” It follows Veronica Sawyer, a high school student who gets involved with the most popular clique at school, the Heathers, and her dangerous new boyfriend, JD. The show explores themes of peer pressure, teen angst, and the consequences of trying to fit in.
Who was in the original Heathers Off-Broadway Cast?
The original Heathers Off-Broadway Cast included Barrett Wilbert Weed as Veronica Sawyer, Ryan McCartan as Jason “J.D.” Dean, Jessica Keenan Wynn as Heather Chandler, Elle McLemore as Heather McNamara, Alice Lee as Heather Duke, and Katie Ladner as Martha Dunnstock, among others.
When did Heathers the Musical open Off-Broadway?
Heathers the Musical officially opened Off-Broadway at New World Stages on March 31, 2014. The show had a successful run, gaining a strong fan following.
How long did Heathers the Musical run Off-Broadway?
Heathers the Musical Off-Broadway ran for a limited engagement from March 2014 until August 4, 2014. Despite its relatively short run, it made a lasting impact and continues to be popular in regional and international productions.
Who wrote the music and lyrics for Heathers the Musical?
The music, lyrics, and book for Heathers the Musical were written by Kevin Murphy and Laurence O’Keefe. Their work combines dark humour with catchy pop-rock songs that reflect the show’s edgy themes.
Where was Heathers the Musical performed Off-Broadway?
Heathers the Musical was performed at New World Stages, an Off-Broadway venue in New York City known for hosting popular and innovative productions.
Was there a cast recording for the Off-Broadway production of Heathers?
Yes, there is an Off-Broadway cast recording of Heathers the Musical, featuring the original cast. The album includes all the major songs from the show and captures the energy and spirit of the Off-Broadway run.
